Reviews

Date Added: Thursday 27 March, 2025

Montecristo Open Eagle Cigar - 1 Single by Nathan

I thought this was very unimpressive for a £50 odd cigar. As one review said, starts off very bland. I gave up after half. I thought the draw was tight and too mild, too smooth and really lacked flavour. Quite disappointed. It was well constructed but burned a little unevenly.

Date Added: Monday 10 March, 2025

Montecristo Petit Edmundo Cigar - 1 Single by Paul

Very well made with perfect draw and burn. Ash lasted a long time and it produced plenty of smoke. Flavour was rich and dark but not too strong, however the last third was fairly hot. Overall a very enjoyable smoke

Date Added: Saturday 08 March, 2025

Mitchellero Peru Toro Cigar - 1 Single by Morgan

Aged for 20 months and benefitted greatly from it. Strong Peruvian flavour but mild in overall strength, doesn’t change much if it all throughout but this is actually a benefit, as in the latter stages where cigars usually would become harsh, instead it remained remarkably smooth. The size feels great in hand and is easily a standout amongst the Mitchellero Peru range

Date Added: Wednesday 05 March, 2025

Mitchellero Corona Cigar - Box of 20 by Paul

Had a box of these as a recent birthday present as I’d really enjoyed one I had in a previous sampler selection. Very pleasant mild smoke and now my cigar of choice for the back 9 on the golf course.

Date Added: Thursday 27 February, 2025

Montecristo No. 4 Cigar - 1 Single by Connor

First time smoking any Montecristo and I have to say it's a great tasting cigar. Burns even, smells great but the draw was sooo tight. I couldn't really fix that. I used a guillotine cutter and even cut a small bit more off part way through smoking and out of pure desperation tried to use a punch where I had already cut. Such a shame really coz the flavours were fantastic. Actually got light-headed from sucking so hard If the draw was a little easier this would be for me and easy 4.5 - 5 star.

Date Added: Thursday 27 February, 2025

Mitchellero Novellini Cigar - 1 Single by Carl

Nice cigar 50 mins smoke time, nice draw, even burn. Smoke increases as you move to the 2nd third. Mild flavour but changes as you progress. Great value for price. Paired mine with JD fire for first half then JD honey and shot of tequila for last 3rd. Stars sweet chocolate then spice into last 3rd. Not much on the retro hale.