Reviews

Date Added: Tuesday 05 August, 2025

Montecristo No. 4 Cigar - Pack of 5 by George

These have long been one of my favourite cigars to enjoy with an afternoon coffee. The classic Cuban flavour is smooth, rich, and never disappoints in taste. Unfortunately, my most recent 5-pack was a letdown. Every stick had a tight draw and required frequent relighting, which took away from the overall experience. It’s a shame, because when they’re good, they’re truly excellent — but the inconsistent quality control makes it a gamble.

Date Added: Monday 04 August, 2025

Joya de Nicaragua Flor De Nicaragua Toro Cigar - 1 Single by Barry

Flawless construction, wrapper is quite veiny but nice looking and oily to touch, nice cold draw with just a touch of resistance using a guillotine cut. Probably the sharpest burn I've seen in a long time, absolutely razor sharp. Ash holds on for 2-3cm revealing a perfect cone, zero relights or corrections needed. Somke is a touch thin but lovely and cool, fairly straightforward flavour with spicy black pepper upfront alongside wood and leather, some subtle sweetness in the background, no strength and light to low medium body. A absolute steal at this price point.

Date Added: Monday 04 August, 2025

Mantis Cigarmaster Guillotine Cutter - Tiffany Blue by Barry

Exceptionally clean cut, absolutely zero tearing of the wrapper and completely straight. The serations on the blades grip the cigar ensuring superb accuracy, no blade wander or cuts at funny angles. Considerably larger than I imagined considering the absolute bargain price, feels really solid and well built, comfortable to use, the inbuilt steel cigar holder is a nice touch.

Date Added: Monday 04 August, 2025

Plasencia Alma Del Cielo Amanecer Hexagono Cigar - 1 Single by Darren

I hate typing up unfavourable reviews, but I think I got unlucky. Let me first stress that this review is unique in as far as it's the first to have been remotely negative as CGars.com have never let me down prior. Sadly this Plascencia was poor from the first cut using a V Cut with a good branded cutter. The wrapper basically fell to pieces and the smoke ended up being tarry and ridiculously harsh. I've had plascencia on many occasions and this surprised me as I've never had a poor one. What you must understand is that cigars are like cars, every now and again you get a lemon. Just to confirm the cigar was kept in my humidor at the perfect humidity and temp.

Date Added: Sunday 03 August, 2025

Vegueros Centrogordos Cigar - 1 Single by Simon

Impeccable construction throughout. The burn required no touch-ups, and the ash held firm in one-inch chunks. The draw was consistent and responsive. A really lovely Cigar and highly recommend for an all round smoke.

Date Added: Sunday 03 August, 2025

Cavalier Geneve White Label Series Elegantes Cigar - 1 Single by Mark

I received this cigar as part of my monthly subscription in June , so it’s sat waiting, and to day was the day to light it up .I read the Description and tasting notes and my cigar did its job From the start I had construction issues, which was a surprise as the notes on the webpage talk about High Quality , but I might have been just unlucky, but I had a nice smoke with nothing to shout about , good ash and it was fine up to the final 3rd, when the outer wrapping just gave up . It had been stored correct. Would I buy one… No it’s not for me … But I would strongly recommend the monthly subscription box as it exposes you to cigars you might not pick , and I’ve had far more good to very good cigars than average ones.. ,