Reviews
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
Mitchellero Novellini Cigar - 1 Single
by Richard
The Mitchellero Novellini was a straightforward smoke that felt very much like an everyday kind of cigar. It’s small and quick, which makes it convenient, but it doesn’t deliver the same depth as some of the larger formats. Flavor-wise, it’s earthy and woody with just a touch of pepper, but it stays fairly one-dimensional throughout. The draw was a bit tight on the one I smoked, though still manageable. The burn was mostly even, and the ash held on better than I expected for a smaller cigar. This isn’t a complex or fancy smoke, but I can see it being handy for situations where you don’t have time for a full robusto or corona. It has a rustic charm, but compared to the Mitchellero Robusto, it felt a little underwhelming. The strength is mild-to-medium, so it’s easy enough for a beginner to handle, though it doesn’t really deliver the same satisfaction as some of the other cigars I’ve tried. Overall, I’d say it works as a casual or quick smoke, but it wouldn’t be my first choice if I had more time.
Rating: 6/10
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
Mitchellero Robusto Cigar - 1 Single
by Richard
The Mitchellero Robusto was a straightforward smoke that felt very much like an everyday kind of cigar. It’s small and quick, which makes it convenient, but it doesn’t deliver the same depth as some of the larger formats. Flavor-wise, it’s earthy and woody with just a touch of pepper, but it stays fairly one-dimensional throughout. The draw was a bit tight on the one I smoked, though still manageable. The burn was mostly even, and the ash held on better than I expected for a smaller cigar. This isn’t a complex or fancy smoke, but I can see it being handy for situations where you don’t have time for a full robusto or corona. It has a rustic charm, but compared to the Mitchellero Robusto, it felt a little underwhelming. The strength is mild-to-medium, so it’s easy enough for a beginner to handle, though it doesn’t really deliver the same satisfaction as some of the other cigars I’ve tried. Overall, I’d say it works as a casual or quick smoke, but it wouldn’t be my first choice if I had more time.
Rating: 6/10
Date Added: Saturday 27 September, 2025
Mitchellero Novellini Cigar - 1 Single
by Jonathon
Just tried this thick stick,had plenty of the standard size mitchelleros.Lovely. Not sure if I’ll move to these over the aforementioned..When I’m not abroad buying my allowance of Nicaraguans.Cgars have never let me down and are my go too,but,Great Britain taxes etc really rub me the wrong way and I hate paying triple! If you haven’t tried mitchelleros,do so now.
Date Added: Friday 26 September, 2025
I was really looking forward to trying this cigar but the flavour profile just didn't do anything for me unfortunately.
It was a well constructed cigar, great even burn all the way till the end and a nice easy smooth draw also. So this isn't a negative review, just wasn't the right cigar for me.
Date Added: Sunday 21 September, 2025
Mitchellero Robusto Cigar - 1 Single
by Simon
I’ve had these Robusto from CGars before. I’ve had this one in the humidor for 6 months at 68% RH and took on holiday to smoke by the pool.
Worth 3 times the price. Beautifully smooth medium smoke. Great construction and burn. 50 minutes with this one.
Well worth a try if you’ve not had one.
Will be ordering a top up for the humidor.
Date Added: Sunday 21 September, 2025
Mitchellero Sporty Cigar - 1 Single
by Stuart
The Mitchellero Sporty was a pleasant surprise. Its a long, thin (not too thin though) cigar that lasted me around 40 minutes, and I found it to be a really enjoyable smoke. There’s a natural sweetness to it, and while my palate isn’t trained enough to pick apart every flavour, I did notice it changed a bit as I went along, each third had something slightly different going on, which kept it interesting.
For the size and the price, I’d say it’s a solid choice, especially if you’re still exploring different cigars and want to try something a little different in shape and profile. It felt like good quality, and I’d happily smoke another one again. A nice, relaxed stick that makes you want to slow down and enjoy the time it gives you.
