Reviews
Date Added: Friday 21 February, 2025
Montecristo No. 4 Cigar - 1 Single
by Stephen
I haven't been smoking cigars long, and this is only my second Montecristo (the other being an Open J, which I really enjoyed), however I had to abandon all hopes as it was almost completely unsmokeable.
I was expecting good things, however it seemed so tight that I was unable to get any sort of useful draw from it.
From other reviews I'm guessing this is more of a consistency issue than anything. Bit at the price point I've had better luck (or at least not as bad luck?) with other cigars.
Quite disappointed
Date Added: Friday 21 February, 2025
A very pleasant little smoke. Exceptionally smooth light body, slightly tight on the draw but honestly I'd rather the draw be too tight than too loose. My only criticism is the price: for such a short smoke it's definitely on the more expensive side, but then again it is a Montecristo! I'll be adding a few more of these to my humidor.
Date Added: Thursday 13 February, 2025
I had one of these last night watching the football & was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was. very nice & Mild. Perfect for a school night without the Dram. I would definitely recommend even for new smokers.
Date Added: Tuesday 11 February, 2025
Extremely easy and enjoyable. Lovely with a peaty malt & my go to Saturday night by the firepit smoke. Always look forward to a My Father and haven't had a bad one yet. Highly recommend and would give 6 stars if I could.
Date Added: Monday 03 February, 2025
Not usually a fan of Cubans I find them a little overrated and have yet to smoke one that I’ve thoroughly enjoyed. That is until now. I purchased my Open Eagle around 3-4 months ago and placed it straight into the humidor out of the tube until yesterday. And I have to say I loved this cigar. Very bland at first with nothing to really shout about other than the beautiful construction but after a while this cigar really began to come into its own. It really was a smoke that I could savour on every draw and just loved it. So the big question is. Is it worth the money? That would have to be a no sadly. I would give this a 5* rating if it was cheaper but at that price sadly it ruined it for me a little or else I’d be buying these in a box.
Date Added: Sunday 02 February, 2025
Great smoke, especially for the price. Not too strong yet full of flavour. Just ordered the 10+2. Probably will become my daily. If your a first timer, I'd highly recommend you give this one a shot. You won't regret it.
