Reviews
Date Added: Thursday 09 October, 2025
Mitchellero Robusto Cigar - 1 Single
by Stuart
The Mitchellero Robusto got full marks from me, 10/10. From start to finish, it felt like I was smoking something expensive, which is always nice for its price point. Big, bold, and satisfying. The burn was totally even, no touch-ups needed, and the draw was solid once it got going.
I smoked mine fresh (I think it came out of my humidor at around 65 % or so) and it delivered. Every third brought something a little different, subtle shifts in flavour, maybe a bit more earth or spice, which kept things interesting. This stick shows they know what they’re doing even on more everyday cigars.
For a robusto sized cigar that feels like it should cost more, this one’s a keeper. Definitely one I’ll make sure to always have in the humidor.
Date Added: Tuesday 07 October, 2025
Mitchellero Robusto Cigar - 1 Single
by David
I purchased this cigar based on the reviews and have to say I was not disappointed. This was a well constructed cigar that burned clean and straight with plenty of smoke. A mild cigar it was a very pleasant smoke which lasted me approximately 60mins. I will be purchasing more!
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
Mitchellero Peru Toro Cigar - 1 Single
by Richard
As someone still new to cigars, the Mitchellero Peru Toro has been a real eye-opener for me. It’s described as an approachable, well-priced smoke, and I can see why it’s a favorite among beginners and more seasoned smokers alike. On the cold draw, I got hints of earth and a touch of cedar, nothing too heavy or intimidating. Once lit, it opened up with a very smooth profile—creamy at times, with light coffee and nutty notes. There’s a bit of pepper, but it doesn’t dominate; it just adds a little tingle that keeps things interesting. The construction was surprisingly solid for the price point—the draw was consistent, and the ash held on longer than I expected. By the halfway point, I noticed some leathery notes and a mild sweetness that reminded me of dried fruit, though very subtle. It’s not overly complex, but it doesn’t need to be; it’s just a straightforward, reliable cigar that delivers plenty of flavor without overwhelming a newcomer. I’d happily recommend this to anyone starting out or looking for an easy daily smoke. For me, this one feels like great value and enjoyable balance
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
As someone still new to cigars, the Mitchellero Peru Robusto has been a real eye-opener for me. It’s described as an approachable, well-priced smoke, and I can see why it’s a favorite among beginners and more seasoned smokers alike. On the cold draw, I got hints of earth and a touch of cedar, nothing too heavy or intimidating. Once lit, it opened up with a very smooth profile—creamy at times, with light coffee and nutty notes. There’s a bit of pepper, but it doesn’t dominate; it just adds a little tingle that keeps things interesting. The construction was surprisingly solid for the price point—the draw was consistent, and the ash held on longer than I expected. By the halfway point, I noticed some leathery notes and a mild sweetness that reminded me of dried fruit, though very subtle. It’s not overly complex, but it doesn’t need to be; it’s just a straightforward, reliable cigar that delivers plenty of flavor without overwhelming a newcomer. I’d happily recommend this to anyone starting out or looking for an easy daily smoke. For me, this one feels like great value and enjoyable bala
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
Mitchellero Novellini Cigar - Box of 20
by Richard
The Mitchellero Novellini was a straightforward smoke that felt very much like an everyday kind of cigar. It’s small and quick, which makes it convenient, but it doesn’t deliver the same depth as some of the larger formats. Flavor-wise, it’s earthy and woody with just a touch of pepper, but it stays fairly one-dimensional throughout. The draw was a bit tight on the one I smoked, though still manageable. The burn was mostly even, and the ash held on better than I expected for a smaller cigar. This isn’t a complex or fancy smoke, but I can see it being handy for situations where you don’t have time for a full robusto or corona. It has a rustic charm, but compared to the Mitchellero Robusto, it felt a little underwhelming. The strength is mild-to-medium, so it’s easy enough for a beginner to handle, though it doesn’t really deliver the same satisfaction as some of the other cigars I’ve tried. Overall, I’d say it works as a casual or quick smoke, but it wouldn’t be my first choice if I had more time.
Rating: 6/10
Date Added: Wednesday 01 October, 2025
Mitchellero Sporty Cigar - Box of 20
by Richard
The Mitchellero Sporty was a straightforward smoke that felt very much like an everyday kind of cigar. It’s small and quick, which makes it convenient, but it doesn’t deliver the same depth as some of the larger formats. Flavor-wise, it’s earthy and woody with just a touch of pepper, but it stays fairly one-dimensional throughout. The draw was a bit tight on the one I smoked, though still manageable. The burn was mostly even, and the ash held on better than I expected for a smaller cigar. This isn’t a complex or fancy smoke, but I can see it being handy for situations where you don’t have time for a full robusto or corona. It has a rustic charm, but compared to the Mitchellero Robusto, it felt a little underwhelming. The strength is mild-to-medium, so it’s easy enough for a beginner to handle, though it doesn’t really deliver the same satisfaction as some of the other cigars I’ve tried. Overall, I’d say it works as a casual or quick smoke, but it wouldn’t be my first choice if I had more time.
Rating: 6/10
